STEM Subject Lab/Packs/NM-LAB-02

Newton’s Third Law.

The cartridge pushes gas backwards, and the gas pushes the car forwards. At the end of the lane the car pushes the stop, and the stop pushes the car. It is the same law at two moments in one race. This pack is built around the one drawing mistake almost everyone makes with it.

Open the simulation Jump to paper sheet

01Learning objectives

01

State Newton’s third law: forces come in pairs that are equal in size, opposite in direction, and act on two different objects.

02

Identify the launch pair (gas and car) and the impact pair (car and stop) in a STEM Racing run.

03

Explain why the two forces in a pair never cancel each other out.

04

Estimate the average stopping force from the car’s kinetic energy and the stopping distance.

02From the Nightmare car

Our launch is a burst of CO₂. Gas leaves the cartridge backwards through the nozzle, and the car gains speed forwards. About one second later the car has to be caught safely at the end of the 20 m lane. People treat these as two different topics, but they are the same law at two different times. We learned the hard way that the catch matters. A car arriving at 20 m/s carries about 11 J, and a badly padded stop sends that energy straight back into the nose.

Two moments, one law A. LAUNCH (the first 0.3 s) gas pushes car (this force is on the car) car pushes gas (this force is on the gas) Same size. Opposite direction. Two different objects. Only the violet arrow belongs on the car’s diagram. B. IMPACT (at about 1.1 s) foam stop pushes car (on the car) car pushesstop The car slows because the only sideways force on it points backwards. Its partner force is on the stop.

Fig. 2 The launch pair and the impact pair. Each arrow is drawn on the object the force acts on. Two arrows on two different objects can never cancel each other.

03Core idea

FA on B = − FB on A Same size. Opposite direction. Always on two different objects. Always the same type of force.

If you draw both arrows on the car, the diagram is wrong. At launch, the forward arrow on the car is “gas pushes car”. The backward arrow belongs on the gas, not on the car. A free-body diagram shows one object and only the forces acting on that object.

Why the car still slows down at the stop

At impact the pair is “stop pushes car” (on the car, backwards) and “car pushes stop” (on the stop, forwards). Only the first one is on the car. So the net force on the car points backwards and the car slows down. The stop feels the other force, which is why the foam squashes and why a solid wall would crack the nose cone.

Favg × d = ½ m v² so Favg = ½mv² / d. This is the average force over the stopping distance d.
!

The classic mistake: “The forces are equal and opposite, so they cancel and nothing moves.” They would only cancel if they acted on the same object. They never do.

04Force-pair animator

Switch between the launch and the impact. Move the thrust slider and watch both arrows change together. They can never be different sizes. Then press “Show the mistake” to see what happens if you draw both arrows on the car.

Both arrows always have the same length. The readouts show what each object does with its half of the pair.

NForce on the car
NForce on the gas
m/s²Car acceleration
NNet force on the car

05Worked example

Claim to test: “The forward and backward forces cancel, so the car should not move.”

Fix: during the launch, the forward force on the car comes from the gas. The backward force from the car acts on the gas. They are equal and opposite, but they are on different objects, so they cannot cancel on the car’s diagram.

Result: the car has a net forward force and speeds up. The gas is pushed backwards. Both things happen. That is the third law working, not failing.

Stopping force: m = 0.055 kg, v = 20 m/s at the stop, and the foam squashes by d = 0.05 m.

KE = ½mv² = 0.5 × 0.055 × 20² = 11 J

Favg = KE / d = 11 / 0.05 = 220 N

220 N is about the weight of a 22 kg child, pushing on a 55 g nose. The stop feels the same 220 N pointing forwards at the same moment. That is why the foam is designed to take it, not the car.

06Student questions Teacher mode is off. Answers are hidden.

Q1 · Identify[2]

Name the two objects in the launch pair, then write the two forces in the form “X pushes Y”.

Answer key

Objects: the gas (CO₂) and the car. Forces: “gas pushes car” (forwards) and “car pushes gas” (backwards). One mark for the objects, one for both forces with directions.

Q2 · Explain[3]

The two forces at the stop are equal and opposite. So why does the car still slow down?

Answer key

The two forces act on different objects (1). “Stop pushes car” acts on the car (1) and it is the only sideways force on the car, so the car has a net backward force and slows down. “Car pushes stop” acts on the stop and does not appear on the car’s diagram (1).

Q3 · Diagram[3]

Sketch the car on its own halfway down the track, coasting. Which force pairs still matter, and which one has already finished?

Answer key

On the car: weight down, the track pushing up, drag backwards, rolling resistance backwards. Partners that still matter: the car pushing down on the track, the car pushing the air forwards, the car pushing on its own axles. Finished: the gas pushing the car, because the cartridge is empty (1). No thrust arrow (1). No backward “reaction to thrust” arrow (1).

Q4 · Calculate[3]

A 0.055 kg car reaches the stop at 20 m/s and the foam squashes by 8 cm. Find the kinetic energy and the average stopping force. What force does the stop feel?

Answer key

KE = ½ × 0.055 × 20² = 11 J

Favg = 11 / 0.08 = 137.5 N ≈ 140 N, backwards, on the car

The stop feels 137.5 N forwards. Same size, opposite direction. One mark each.